Probation and parole give people a second chance. They give people a chance to serve their time outside of a prison cell, start over, and become a useful member of society. But there are strict rules and conditions that come with this freedom. One mistake, like missing an appointment with an officer or failing a drug test, can put that freedom in danger. The idea of breaking probation or parole can make people very scared and unsure. But a hearing for a violation is not the end of the line. To protect your rights and fight to stay free, it's important to know how the process works, what the legal steps are, and what defense strategies are available. This guide is meant to make this difficult process easier to understand and give you the information you need to make a strong case for yourself.
The Foundation: Probation vs. Parole
Before you can understand the violation process, it's essential to understand the difference between probation and parole. While both involve a period of supervision, they are fundamentally different.
Probation is a sentence given by a judge instead of jail or prison time. It is a period of supervision that a person serves in the community. The conditions of probation, such as meeting with a probation officer, attending counseling, or paying fines, are a part of the original sentence.
Parole is a period of supervision that a person serves after they have been released from prison. It is an early release from a prison sentence. The conditions of parole are designed to help a person transition back into society and are monitored by a parole officer.
While the legal terms are different, the process for a violation is similar and is handled by either a judge or a parole board.
Types of Violations: Technical vs. New Law Violations
A violation of probation or parole can be a wide range of actions. It's crucial to understand the difference between the two main types, as they can have different legal consequences.
Technical Violations: These are violations of the rules of supervision. They do not involve the commission of a new crime. Technical violations often include the following examples.
Missing a scheduled meeting with your probation or parole officer.
Failing a drug or alcohol test.
Failing to pay a court-ordered fine or restitution.
Not reporting a change in your address or employment.
Traveling outside of a designated area without permission.
Missing a mandated counseling session.
New Law Violations: This is a much more serious type of violation. It occurs when a person is arrested for or charged with a new crime while under supervision. This is often an automatic violation of probation or parole. A new law violation can range from a minor offense like a traffic violation to a serious crime like a DUI or a felony charge.
While a technical violation can result in a return to jail, a new law violation will almost certainly lead to a more severe outcome and a return to prison.
The Violation Process: A Step-by-Step Guide
The process of a violation is methodical, but it moves quickly. Understanding these steps can help you be prepared and know what to expect.
Step 1: The Report and Arrest
The process begins when your probation or parole officer files an official report with the court or the parole board. The report will detail the alleged violation and recommend a course of action. Based on this report, a warrant may be issued for your arrest.
Step 2: The Violation Hearing
This is the core of the process. A violation hearing is not a criminal trial. It is a more informal proceeding where a judge or a parole board will hear the evidence.
Lower Standard of Proof: In a criminal trial, the prosecutor must prove guilt "beyond a reasonable doubt." In a violation hearing, the standard of proof is much lower. The prosecutor only has to prove that a violation occurred by a "preponderance of the evidence," which means it is more likely than not that the violation occurred.
No Jury: There is no jury at a violation hearing. The decision is made solely by a judge or a parole board.
The Right to an Attorney: You have the right to be represented by a qualified attorney at a violation hearing. This is a non-negotiable right, and in many cases, an attorney can be the difference between a return to freedom and a return to prison.
Step 3: The Hearing's Outcome
After hearing the evidence from both sides, the judge or parole board will make a finding. The possible outcomes of a violation hearing are as follows.
No Violation Found: The judge or parole board finds that the violation did not occur, and you are released from the violation charge.
Violation Found, but with a New, Modified Sentence: The judge or parole board finds that a violation occurred but decides to impose a new, less severe sentence, such as an extension of your supervision, a new fine, or a short jail sentence.
Violation Found, and the Original Sentence Is Imposed: The judge or parole board finds that a violation occurred and decides to impose the original sentence, which can mean a return to prison to serve out the remainder of your sentence.
Defense Strategies: How to Prepare for a Violation Hearing
Even if a violation occurred, you are not without options. A violation hearing is a chance for you to present your side of the story and argue for a better outcome.
Challenge the Allegation: Your attorney can challenge the allegation itself. For example, if you are accused of missing a meeting, your attorney can present evidence, such as a time-stamped photo or a witness statement, that proves you were there. If you are accused of failing a drug test, your attorney can challenge the accuracy of the test.
Presenting Mitigating Factors: Even if a violation occurred, you can present mitigating factors to the judge. This is your chance to show that you have made a good-faith effort to comply with your supervision. Examples of mitigating factors include the following.
You had a legitimate reason for the violation, such as a family emergency or a medical issue.
You have been in compliance with all other conditions of your supervision.
You have a stable job and strong ties to the community.
The Role of the Attorney: A skilled attorney is essential for this. They can help you prepare your case, present evidence, and negotiate with the probation or parole officer and the judge. An attorney can also help you understand the specific rules of your jurisdiction and can fight to protect your rights.
FAQ: Your Questions About Violations Answered
Q: Can I go to jail for a technical violation?
A: Yes, you can. While a technical violation is often seen as less serious than a new law violation, it can still result in a return to jail or prison.
Q: What is the difference between a probation violation and a new crime?
A: A probation violation is an administrative action that is handled by a judge or a parole board. A new crime is a criminal charge that is handled in a criminal trial. You can face both a violation hearing and a criminal trial for the same act.
Q: What are my rights at a violation hearing?
A: You have the right to an attorney, the right to present evidence, and the right to have witnesses testify on your behalf. However, you do not have the right to a jury trial.
Q: Can I get a court-appointed lawyer for a violation hearing?
A: Yes, you can. In many cases, if you cannot afford an attorney, the court will appoint one for you.
Q: How does this affect my original sentence?
A: A judge or parole board can revoke your probation or parole and order you to serve out your original sentence, so a violation can have a very severe impact on your freedom.
Disclaimer
This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Probation and parole laws, the violation process, and the potential consequences are complex and vary significantly by jurisdiction. This information should not be used as a substitute for professional legal guidance. For personalized advice, it is imperative to consult with a qualified attorney.
Comments
Post a Comment